Wednesday, March 11, 2015

The Star Wars Saga

Disclaimer: I haven't given this a thorough proofreading pass, so I apologize for any errors. I'm just going to publish it as-is, though, as I want to get it published, rather than have it languish in "I still need to proofread that" land.

So, I recently got it into my head to re-watch the Star Wars Saga. I now want to share my thoughts. The first major observation I have is that I am quite thoroughly convinced that the original trilogy and the prequal trilogy belong to different continuities. There is no way I can believe that they belong to the same continuity, as the inconsistencies are too great.
I'm going to start by ranking the films, by episode. This is rough, and I'm not 100% on it beyond the first and last items:
1) Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back - Not an uncommon choice, I have heard. Incidentally, if the credits are to go by, the one with the least amount of direct impact by George Lucas. I'll talk more about my opinions about the films later, but wish to give some initial comment here.
2) Episode III: Revenge of the Sith - This is probably quite unusual. It suffers from many of the common problems, but the underlying (and admittedly too subtle) plot is very deep, complex, and interesting. It is a pity it doesn't show through very well.
3) Episode IV: A New Hope, Episode VI: Return of the Jedi, and Episode I: The Phantom Menace - Honestly, I'm not quite sure what order I place these in. I do roughly feel that Episode IV is vying for a tied spot with Episode III. Overall, I feel that all of these films have a lot that is great about them with a lot that drags them down.
4) Episode II: Attack of the Clones - The "romance" kills this film for me. It kills it very, very thoroughly. There are some great moments in here, but they can't overcome the sheer awkwardness of basically any scene featuring both Padme and Anakin.

It now seems to me to be a good time to address the elephant in the room: George Lucas. I think he is a good storysmith, creative, and world builder. I do not think he is a very good director, and his dialog leaves much to be desired. Also, he isn't an editor, I don't think. I do think he gets an unfortunately severe bad rap, and I also think that the films have had a lot of very skilled people doing very good work. It is unfortunate that so much of the skill and ability that went into the creation of the films (particularly the prequal trilogy) are forgotten due to failings on the most important part of films, but it is also understandable.

I feel that where the Star Wars films fail, it is due to questionable shots/scenes, poor pacing, and awkward dialog. I think many of the actors (again, particularly the prequal trilogy) are better than direction and editing choices show.

Also, Jar Jar actually has one very brilliant, excellent scene. It is a pity that every other scene with him has him playing the awkward comic relief where none is needed. His gags are purely for the audience, not for the other characters in the film. That is where he fails. Those sorts of scenes -- ones meant entirely for the audience, not for the plot or the characters (such as Jar Jar stepping in dung or being farted on) -- break the fourth wall. Such things are fine in the right sort of film. Star Wars films are not the right sort of film.

I suppose I don't have much more I want to put here, so I think I'll go over my sort of overall thoughts on each film. Keep in mind that I watched them in numeric order (1-6), having most recently watched Episode VI, so my memories of the earlier films may be a bit foggier.

Episode I: A Phantom Menace

One of the thoughts that struck me upon reflection on this film is that the main character -- as much as this film has one -- is Padme. If you think about it, it starts with the Jedi going to help her, and the plot is primarily moved along by seeing to her wants and needs. This is particularly true in the latter portion of the film, when it is her decision to return to Naboo and go to war against the Trade Federation.

The Pod Racing scene is excessively long, and the introduction of the pilots is unnecessary. They would be perfectly fine if the film was about pod racing. It isn't, though this scene does its best to try to convince us otherwise. We don't really need to see most of the race.

I already commented above about Jar Jar Binks. I understand why he is hated, but I also feel some of that hate is overblown. The character is handled poorly, and isn't given a serious role to fill save the once, and he does well there.

Darth Maul is pretty neat; its a shame that he gets killed off. A sentiment I understand is shared.

Jake Lloyd, poor guy, sounds like he is shouting the majority of his lines. No wonder he has such a hard time emoting. That is a directorial issue, I think.

This has been commented on elsewhere, but why is Anakin taken back to Naboo, instead of being left on Coruscant? I've no idea on this, it makes little sense.

I love the designs for Naboo, and Padme has fantastic outfits.

Episode II: Attack of the Clones

This film is very polarized. Basically, if Anakin is on screen, chances are the dialog will be super awkward and unfortunately off-putting. Otherwise, it is mostly fine. Unfortunately, Anakin appears in much of the film. This is predominately a dialog problem, of course.

Overall, Padme has great outfits again.

Kamino is pretty neat. I don't understand the scene with Yoda and the younglings with Obi-wan asking about the missing planet, but whatever.

Honestly, I don't have much more to say. Anakin and Padme have no real romance, the dialog is mostly awkward, and Obi-wan does interesting stuff. There's a reason the LEGO game jumps pretty much straight to Geonosis.

I like Mace Windu's purple lightsaber.

Episode III: Revenge of the Sith

The reasons I like this film so much more than most of the rest of the Star Wars films is due to so much of the underlying subtext. Seeing the interplay and interactions between Anakin, Palpatine, and the Jedi Council is very fascinating. Anakin's defection, and ultimate opposition to the Jedi Order is entirely upon the Jedis' head. Palpatine may plant the ideas, but the Jedi confirm them by their actions. Their lack of trust for Anakin is what ends up turning him against them.

It's very fascinating to see it all play out, but it requires watching the film closely. It helps to be acquainted with the book. The other did whatever the opposite of phoning something in is, and it can help give you some insight into mindset stuff that does show in the film if you know to look for it.

Warning: For Episodes IV, V, and VI, I watched the Special Editions. I will overall avoid commenting on continuity issues, only pointing to areas where I feel it points to a prominent lack of continuity between the Original Trilogy and the Prequel Trilogy, not every possible instance. I will also probably not mention any subtle changes that happened with the special editions.

Episode IV: A New Hope

I was honestly surprised with how poorly I felt this film held up. It feels like it drags, and the Cantina introduction scene -- where all of these aliens are shown off -- feels extremely pointless in this day and age. They no longer have those aliens as a cool thing to show off, so now those shots feel like they are just wasting time.

The first big area that generates a feeling of discontinuity to me with the prequels occurs in the first discussion that Obi-wan has with Luke. The overall feeling I get from the conversation doesn't match up at all with what is presented in the prequels. Speaking of that conversation, I like how the movie uses Luke's lack of knowledge about the Force to tell the viewer about it. That worked well, I think.

On the Han Shot First (TM) thing, the editing there is definitely awkward (though I feel like I remember it being worse the last time I watched the film), and that is my biggest issue with it. The only other thing that bothers me (and it bothers me a LOT) is the entirely unnecessary scene with Han and Jabba in front of the Falcon. Not only is the CGI kinda bad looking, not only is the editing to have Han walk on Jabba's tail, not only is it bad for Jabba (character assassination, especially after that tail step, and I think the Ep. VI intro is better for him), but the scene is entirely redundant with Greedo's scene, which explains all of the same information. Other edits (more ships, for example) I'm fine with.

I should also mention that it bugs me that it takes almost an hour (OK, less without the needless Jabba scene, but still) to get off of Tatooine. Also, the dialog audio quality was all over the place, something that got better with each subsequent film. I shall make no further mention of that particular thing.

Overall, the film isn't bad, but there are quite a few areas that feel like they drag quite a bit. Some of it is due to showing off the stuff they did that was special in 1977, but isn't any longer. I was surprised by how much better I thought the Obi-wan and Vader fight was compared to how I remembered it. Maybe I have more respect for the fight due to more familiarity with the sword styles used. Also, there is a really hilarious line that Obi-wan gets, when he and Luke run across the ruined Jawa transport, about the high precision of Imperial Stormtroopers.

Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back

This was the only film of the saga that managed to suck me in enough that my critic brain didn't turn on during the watching of it. I'm not sure much else needs to be said. The dialog in this episode is probably some of the best in the entire saga, and it feels like a very cohesive film, and the pacing in this film is the best of the six as well, in my opinion. Also, and this is more of a retrospect thing, but the locations in this film feel the most exotic, which I like as well. Not much more to say here, other than to note that it is the film that has the least involvement from Lucas, according to the credits. Take that for what you will.

Episode VI: Return of the Jedi

OK, so I just watched this, so it might be a little more detailed and a little less cohesive. That said, why on earth does rescuing Han take a full quarter of the film? Not that I dislike those scenes, but they don't feel super connected to the rest of the film. I suppose there is some mild tonal stuff with Luke, but that could easily have been handled in a way that felt more connected. Or, you know, just briefer. Also, I'm fairly confidant I'm not the only one that fines the Twi'lek females more attractive than Leia's slave costume. I do like that they gave the Jabba kill to Leia.

I have no direct problem with the concept of the Ewoks, but frankly, they're like less prepared Gungans, and the scenes with them drag on and on. I do like Luke floating C-3P0 around. I see no reason for us to sit through C-3P0 going over their adventures in a foreign language, though. I do think the rather large rocks that the Ewoks employ would be fairly effective against armor in general, though I know little about the specifics of the supposed quality of Stormtrooper armor. Their preparation is rather startling, though.

Leia talking about her mother totally contradicts with the ending of Episode III.

I like the ending showing celebrations across the galaxy, nevermind how silly such an immediate thing would possibly be. Also, interesting fact: Hayden Christensen had no idea he was being inserted in the ending. It was done entirely without his knowledge.

Conclusion:

Overall, I feel that the films are most valuable from a worldbuilding standpoint. The predominate issues have to do with direction, pacing, editing, and dialog. Most of these are related, and can generally be summed up as: George Lucas is very good at certain things, and not as good at other things that he kept doing.